Waldo wrote an essay about Columbus proves the earth is flat. He’s say’s Stinky Redmond stole it. So, when they got to the carousel, Waldo got on to a white horse three horses in front of the black horse. At the end Stinky gave back Waldo’s essay because Stinky didn’t want to get punched in the face by Sally’s big fists. I like the part where Stinky gave back Waldo’s essay. Stinky also had an essay. Because as soon as the carousel started Stinky went straight to the bench and was reading Waldo’s essay to notice Stinky’s mistake. I do not like the part where Stinky was lying and took Waldo’s essay. Because Stinky also said he wrote Waldo’s essay. He was wrong. And Stinky said he had gotten sick after going up and down on the carousel. But the black horse had only one hoof off the ground. Any horse with three (or four) feet on the ground doesn’t go up and down it doesn’t move at all Stinky couldn’t have gotten sick. thanks to Encyclopedia sharp brain and Waldo’s sharp eye, Waldo got his essay back.